top of page
Search

Equal Parenting Time in Ontario pursuant to P. v. W., 2026 ONSC 2553

Writer: Jared Davies, Lawyer
Jared Davies, Lawyer
10 minutes ago
4 min read

A parenting schedule can divide a young child's waking hours equally without giving each parent equal parenting time overall. An Ontario judgment illustrates why the timing of exchanges, overnight care and school-day transitions can matter just as much as the apparent number of visits.


In P. v. W., 2026 ONSC 2553, released May 6, 2026, Justice Heeney of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice accepted a father's proposal to adjust an existing schedule to equal parenting time. The Office of the Children's Lawyer supported the proposed changes.


What was the parenting arrangement before trial?


The case concerned a four-year-old child. The parents had resolved virtually all their other disputes through earlier consent orders and an April 2, 2026 final order following judicial mediation. The settled matters included joint decision-making responsibility and issues concerning communication, health, schooling, religion and extracurricular activities. Property and spousal support matters were also settled.


Only the allocation of parenting time remained for trial. An earlier interim, without-prejudice order made in March 2025 had adopted the existing schedule. Under that arrangement, the child spent essentially equal waking hours with each parent, but the mother collected the child from the father's residence at 8:15 p.m. on certain parenting days. As a consequence, the mother had more overnight care, and the father's overall parenting time was approximately 35%.


What change did the father request?


The father proposed allowing the child to remain overnight with him on two nights per week and following his alternate weekends, instead of being returned to the mother at 8:15 p.m. The child would then take the school bus the following morning, with the next portion of the mother's parenting time beginning after the school day.


This would bring the allocation of both waking and overnight time to an equal 50/50 arrangement. The mother asked the court to maintain the status quo. The Office of the Children's Lawyer's report, prepared February 25, 2026, supported the father's proposal.


Why did the court approve equal parenting time?


Justice Heeney accepted the father's proposed schedule. The judgment's central practical concern was the disruption associated with late-evening transitions shortly before the child's bedtime. Allowing the child to remain overnight and transition through the school-day routine provided a more stable arrangement.


The court found that both parents were capable caregivers, that the child had loving relationships with both, and that the parents generally communicated civilly while shielding the child from conflict. The court gave little weight to dated and exaggerated allegations that undermined the father's parenting abilities. These broader best-interests findings were important to the decision (paras. 31-38, 57-59, 79-82).


The significance of this decision is that the father was not asking to create a wholly new relationship with the child or dramatically increase waking-hours contact. The parties had already divided the child's waking hours equally. The change concerned where the child slept on those nights and the timing of the following transition.


The outcome should not be treated as a presumption that 50/50 parenting time is always appropriate. Parenting decisions must be assessed according to the particular child's best interests, including age, routine, stability and each parent's ability to meet the child's needs.


Under section 24(6) of Ontario's Children's Law Reform Act, a child should have as much time with each parent as is consistent with the child's best interests. This is not a presumption that every family must have a 50/50 schedule.


Did the parents' work schedules matter?


Both parents worked demanding shifts: the father was a firefighter with 24-hour shifts and the mother was a paramedic working rotating 12-hour shifts. Their circumstances show why a parenting arrangement cannot always be assessed by counting conventional weekdays or weekends alone.


The father's partner lived with him and had a close relationship with the child. The judge accepted that the father could arrange short work coverage to assist with the school-bus departure at about 7:20 a.m., and that his partner or nearby grandparents could provide appropriate morning help when necessary. The parents' homes were also about a five-minute walk apart (paras. 18, 74-77).


Where parents work irregular hours, a practical parenting plan should address actual availability, overnight care, the school schedule, and who will handle transportation. The court's decision in this case turned on the child's best interests, not simply a mathematical entitlement to half the overnights.


What did equal parenting time mean for child support?


Under the prior arrangement, the father paid the full table amount of child support because his parenting time was approximately 35%. The parties agreed that, if the court ordered equal parenting time, support would be calculated on a table-offset basis. The resulting final order required the father to pay $184 per month (para. 95).


That agreement should not be mistaken for a universal rule. Under section 9 of Ontario's Child Support Guidelines, shared parenting arrangements involving at least 40% of the parenting time for each parent require consideration of both table amounts, increased shared-parenting costs, and the spouses' and child's circumstances. The applicable law and facts may require more than a simple subtraction of table figures.


What can Ontario parents learn from P. v. W.?


This decision illustrates that a careful adjustment to exchange times can substantially affect the legal allocation of parenting time while preserving much of the child's existing daily routine. It also demonstrates the potential value of an OCL assessment when a judge must choose between competing parenting plans.


When proposing additional overnight time, parents should explain why the schedule works for the child: the bedtime routine, school or daycare exchanges, transportation, caregiving responsibilities, and the impact on the child's stability. The analysis remains child-centred, rather than a contest over identical numbers of nights.


This case concerned an unresolved parenting-time issue decided at trial, not an application to change a final parenting-time order. Where a final parenting order already governs the schedule, section 29(1) of the Children's Law Reform Act generally requires a material change in circumstances affecting or likely to affect the child's best interests before the court may vary it.


Ottawa Parenting Time Lawyer


If you are seeking a change to parenting time or opposing an equal parenting schedule, speak with an Ottawa parenting time lawyer about the evidence, available options and the practical details of a parenting plan.


This article provides general information about Ontario family law, not legal advice. Every parenting dispute turns on its own facts and the child's best interests.

 
 

This site cannot provide, or be a supplement to, legal advice. This blog post does not account for the unique facts of your individual case. There is no guarantee the information in the enclosed blog post is accurate or up to date. Information which appears on this website is general legal information only and does not create a solicitor-client relationship. If you need advice based upon your own particular situation, please speak to a lawyer.

185 Pembroke St E, Pembroke, ON K8A 3J6

By Appointment Only

224 Cooper St, Ottawa, ON K2P 0G4

By Appointment Only

bottom of page