Child Relocation in Ontario pursuant to E. v. M., 2026 ONSC 4372

Can a parent move to another Ontario city with their child when the other parent objects? The answer depends on the child's best interests, the existing parenting arrangement, and the evidence supporting each parent's proposed plan.
In E. v. M., 2026 ONSC 4372, released July 28, 2026, Justice Piccoli permitted a mother to relocate her almost four-year-old son from Cambridge to Ottawa. The decision is noteworthy because the Office of the Children's Lawyer (OCL) had recommended against the move.
Background: A proposed move from Cambridge to Ottawa
The parties separated in October 2022, shortly after their son was born. Under an interim parenting order made in August 2024, the child spent approximately 80% of his time in his mother's care and the remaining time with his father.
The mother planned to move to Ottawa, where her partner worked in a specialized Canadian Armed Forces position. The mother and her partner also had a daughter who had developed a strong bond with the child. The proposed move would allow them to establish one household, providing greater financial and practical stability.
The father opposed the relocation. He wanted to preserve his frequent contact with the child in Cambridge and raised concerns about the long drive, the child's existing support network, and the impact on the father-child relationship.
Which parent had the burden of proof?
As the parties were not married, the Children's Law Reform Act (CLRA) governed the relocation dispute. Under section 39.4(6), where the parties have substantially complied with an order, family arbitration award or agreement providing that a child spends the vast majority of time with the parent proposing to move, the parent opposing relocation must show that the move is not in the child's best interests.
Justice Piccoli considered the Ontario Court of Appeal authorities Shipton v. Shipton, 2024 ONCA 624, and Angelillo v. Mughal, 2025 ONCA 769. The mother had approximately 80% of the child's parenting time, and the parties had substantially complied with the interim order. The father therefore bore the burden of proving that relocation would not be in the child's best interests.
The court did not decline to apply that statutory burden merely because the parenting schedule arose from an interim order. However, the judge acknowledged that different circumstances, including a deliberately engineered status quo or parental alienation, could potentially justify an exercise of discretion.
The court applied the combined best-interests factors in sections 24 and 39.4(3) of the CLRA, drawing on Barendregt v. Grebliunas, 2022 SCC 22. It also noted that the mother had complied with the statutory relocation notice requirements (paras. 63-65, 77-80).
Why the court disagreed with the OCL
The OCL's December 2024 report recommended that the mother not relocate with the child and that the father receive additional parenting time. The court respected the clinician's experience but found the relocation recommendation flawed for several reasons.
The report was prepared when the child was just over two years old. By trial, he was nearly four and had travelled to Ottawa monthly; the court heard no evidence that the drive had negatively affected him. The child's younger sister was born after the report, so the clinician could not yet assess the siblings' later close relationship. Crucially, the OCL's recommendation assumed both parents would remain in Cambridge rather than comparing the actual alternatives of the child living in Ottawa with his mother or remaining in Cambridge with his father.
The court also found that family violence and its impact were not addressed in the OCL report. Following the trial evidence, Justice Piccoli found that the father had perpetrated family violence against the mother.
The case illustrates that an OCL recommendation is evidence to be weighed, not a substitute for the court's own best-interests analysis. A clinician's assumptions, the age of the report, and subsequent developments may affect the weight given to the recommendation.
Primary caregiver, siblings and the child's stability
Justice Piccoli emphasized that the child had lived primarily with his mother since birth. He had close relationships with both parents and extended family members, but his strongest attachment was to his mother. He was also closely bonded to his younger sister.
The mother's move would allow the children to grow up together and would provide the support of her partner. The court accepted that her partner's military employment required him to reside in Ottawa. The mother had researched schooling, childcare and housing arrangements.
Conversely, the father's rotating shift-work schedule meant that his proposal to have the child reside primarily in Cambridge would require considerable care by the paternal grandparents. It would also separate the child from his mother and younger sister for much of his day-to-day life.
The proper comparison in a relocation case
Section 39.4(4) of the CLRA prohibits the court from considering whether the relocating parent would abandon the move if the child were not permitted to relocate, often called the double-bind problem. Justice Piccoli instead compared two realistic alternatives: the child relocating to Ottawa with his mother or remaining in Cambridge with his father.
After considering the statutory relocation factors and the child's overall best interests, the court concluded that the father had not discharged his burden. Relocation to Ottawa was allowed.
Parenting time and travel arrangements after relocation
The relocation order preserved a substantial role for the father. He was entitled to a minimum of two weekends per month with the child, one in Cambridge and one in Ottawa, along with video calls at least three times weekly for a minimum of 30 minutes.
The court acknowledged that relocation would mean the child saw his father less frequently, but found that the new parenting schedule would give the father more total parenting time (para. 100).
The court expanded the mother's summer proposal and ordered four weeks of parenting time for the father under the regular summer schedule, with a transitional provision for two non-consecutive weeks in summer 2026. The decision also set detailed holiday arrangements, including Christmas, March Break, Father's Day, Easter and Thanksgiving.
The mother was responsible for specified travel expenses under the regular schedule. The court also ordered reimbursement of up to $500 per calendar month for the father's Ottawa parenting-time travel ($150 for travel and $350 for accommodation), but only if he travelled to Ottawa to exercise parenting time, incurred overnight accommodation expenses, and provided a receipt confirming suitable overnight accommodation no later than 14 days after the Ottawa parenting time concluded. The mother received sole decision-making responsibility, with an obligation to consult the father on major decisions, and joint responsibility for extracurricular activities affecting his parenting time.
Additional orders regarding child support and communication
The court ordered the father to pay $5,962.40 in retroactive child support and $1,050 per month in ongoing child support commencing June 1, 2026, based on a Guidelines income of $114,722. The parties were also ordered to communicate about the child in writing through AppClose (order, paras. 25, 35-36).
What E. v. M. means for Ontario parents
This decision demonstrates why the established allocation of parenting time, the quality and timeliness of professional assessments, sibling relationships and a practical plan for long-distance parenting can all be decisive in relocation cases.
A parent who wishes to move should be prepared to provide detailed evidence about housing, schooling, childcare, transportation and how the other parent's relationship with the child will be maintained. A parent opposing relocation must address the actual alternatives rather than assume the other parent will stay if the move is refused.
Speak with an Ottawa parenting time lawyer
Relocation cases involve important questions about where a child will live, who will make major decisions, and what parenting arrangements will continue after a move.
For advice about your own circumstances, speak with an Ottawa parenting time lawyer about parenting time, relocation and decision-making responsibility.
This article provides general information about Ontario family law and is not legal advice. Every relocation dispute turns on its particular facts and evidence.


